Google, Apple say no to UK intelligence agency’s plan to listen in on encrypted chats
Google, Apple, Microsoft, WhatsApp and numerous other companies and organizations have publicly opposed a proposal by the UK's intelligence agency GCHQ to open up encrypted communication to the government.
In an open letter to GCHQ, dated May 22, the group addresses a proposal published by GCHQ in November 2018. While the letter says that the "principles set forth by GCHQ officials are an important step in the right direction," it criticizes the proposal for “silently adding a law enforcement participant to a group chat or call,” also referred to as the "ghost proposal."
Essentially, the GCHQ wants messaging services such as Facebook's Messenger, WhatsApp and Signal to put in a switch that would enable the UK government to snoop on any encrypted chat. And while the GCHQ's proposal insists this is "not about weakening encryption or defeating the end-to-end nature of the service," Google, Apple and other signees of the letter claim that such a proposal would "pose serious threats to cybersecurity and thereby also threaten fundamental human rights, including privacy and free expression."
The letter lists several reasons why the ghost proposal is a horrible idea. It undermines the authentication process and it could introduce new (unintentional) security flaws into encrypted communication systems. It would also undermine users' trust into such systems, and opens up new avenues for abuse -- would you trust your encrypted chat to be really private if you knew there could be a government official reading every word you wrote?
In conclusion, the signees of the letter urge GCHQ to abandon the ghost proposal, as well as "avoid any alternate approaches that would similarly threaten digital security and human rights."
Besides the tech giants listed above, the signees of the open letter include civil society organizations like the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Human Rights Watch, as well as several security experts.
In response, Ian Levy, one of the authors of the proposal, told The Guardian that "we welcome this response to our request for thoughts on exceptional access to data -- for example to stop terrorists. The hypothetical proposal was always intended as a starting point for discussion. We will continue to engage with interested parties and look forward to having an open discussion to reach the best solutions possible.”
Featured Video For You
Facebook reveals its 'privacy-focused vision for social networking'
-
NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29石棉县人民法院“诚信石棉”让诚信之光照耀棉城Defector group sends propaganda leaflets into North Korea in defiance of ban[Exclusive] BlueOval SK’s Kentucky plant to start production in 1st half of 2025: officialUnderstanding Relational vs. Non雅安中学选派教师赴山东“取经”Joss Whedon revelations: Fans react为什么五月一定要去高州?Korea's economy to stop growing without drastic labor change: FKINorth Korean leader presides over politburo meeting in first public appearance in a month
下一篇:NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29
- ·World’s first ‘meltdown
- ·荥经工商开展“光彩服务日”活动
- ·South Korea refrains from commenting on Kim Jong
- ·2.6 slight tremor occurs in Incheon
- ·Bernie Sanders’ DNC speech sounded like everyone else’s. That’s astonishing.
- ·石棉县人民法院“诚信石棉”让诚信之光照耀棉城
- ·Breitbart created a Steve Bannon fidget spinner for the adult baby in your life
- ·Apple's iPhone 13 will come with faster 5G in more countries, report claims
- ·应对高温 户外驿站送清凉
- ·Rohit Sharma backs Virat Kohli performance for T20 World Cup final
- ·渔公子|天气何止是个梗
- ·Leaders of Korea, Uzbekistan agree to bolster ties
- ·SpaceX Polaris Dawn mission: How to watch the launch
- ·2.6 slight tremor occurs in Incheon
- ·2 people fall from amusement park ride in Wolmido
- ·Defenders of the North get the 'Game of Thrones' Photoshop battle they deserve
- ·Eng name ODI, T20I squads for Aus series
- ·Watch a very cute kid crash a TV segment about milk allergies
- ·雨城区中里镇中心校举行法制和交通安全教育报告会
- ·'Joker and Harley Quinn' movie coming to Warner Bros. with Jared Leto and Margot Robbie
- ·18 Slightly Submerged Architectural Wonders
- ·North Korea completed new 3,000
- ·山雅茶业 新包装系列化上市三部曲
- ·Earth just had its second
- ·Apple finally sends out payments for MacBook's butterfly keyboard settlement
- ·Kylie Jenner finally spills what led to her breakup with Tyga
- ·Webb scientists haven't found a rocky world with air. But now they have a plan.
- ·Breitbart created a Steve Bannon fidget spinner for the adult baby in your life
- ·Rohit Sharma backs Virat Kohli performance for T20 World Cup final
- ·市公安局交警支队车管所放弃假日全员加班提供“检车”便民服务
- ·A Global Tour of Bakeries With Fascinating Histories
- ·AI virus detected in wild bird droppings
- ·Earth just had its second
- ·全力推进国道108线示范工程改造施工
- ·NASA rover snaps photo of its most daunting challenge yet
- ·名山县对选调乡镇国土员进行岗前培训