Signal warns it could stop operating in U.S. if anti
Signal is warning that an anti-encryption bill circulating in Congress could force the private messaging app to pull out of the US market.
Since the start of the coronavirus pandemic, the free app, which offers end-to-end encryption, has seen a surge in traffic. But on Wednesday, the nonprofit behind the app published a blog post, raising the alarm around the EARN IT Act. “At a time when more people than ever are benefiting from these (encryption) protections, the EARN IT bill proposed by the Senate Judiciary Committee threatens to put them at risk,” Signal developer Joshua Lund wrote in the post.
Although the goal of the legislation, which has bipartisan support, is to stamp out online child exploitation, it does so by letting the US government regulate how internet companies should combat the problem—even if it means undermining the end-to-end encryption protecting your messages from snoops.
If the companies fail to do so, they risk losing legal immunity under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which can shield them from lawsuits concerning objectionable or illegal content posted on their websites or apps.
“Some large tech behemoths could hypothetically shoulder the enormous financial burden of handling hundreds of new lawsuits if they suddenly became responsible for the random things their users say, but it would not be possible for a small nonprofit like Signal to continue to operate within the United States,” Lund wrote in the blog post.
Why Signal is concerned the bill will undermine end-to-end encryption is because it gives US Attorney General William Barr— a major critic of encryption— the power to dictate how internet companies fight online child exploitation. In recent months, Barr has been calling on Facebook to reverse a plan to expand end-to-end encryption across its services, on claims the technology is preventing law enforcement from tracking down criminals, including child sex offenders.
“Companies should not deliberately design their systems to preclude any form of access to content, even for preventing or investigating the most serious crimes,” Barr wrote to Facebook back in October. “This puts our citizens and societies at risk by severely eroding a company’s ability to detect and respond to illegal content and activity, such as child sexual exploitation and abuse, terrorism.”
However, Signal says the efforts to undermine end-to-end encryption risk doing more harm to innocent users than actual criminals, who will simply choose other ways to mask their activities online. “If easy-to-use software like Signal somehow became inaccessible, the security of millions of Americans (including elected officials and members of the armed forces) would be negatively affected,” Lund added. “Meanwhile, criminals would just continue to use widely available (but less convenient) software to jump through hoops and keep having encrypted conversations.”
The EARN IT Act opposed by privacy advocates and tech lobbying groups but has received support from six Democratic US senators and four Republican senators. “Our goal is to do this in a balanced way that doesn’t overly inhibit innovation, but forcibly deals with child exploitation,” US Senator Lindsey Graham (R-South Carolina) said last month in announcing the legislation.
“Simply put, tech companies need to do better,” added Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-Connecticut). “Tech companies have an extraordinary special safeguard against legal liability, but that unique protection comes with a responsibility.”
But other lawmakers say they're against the bill, citing its potential to be abused. "This terrible legislation is a Trojan horse to give Attorney General Barr and Donald Trump the power to control online speech and require government access to every aspect of Americans' lives," said Senator Ron Wyden (D-Oregon) last month.
-
Coach jailed for sexual exploitation of underage athleteNorth Korea nuclear talks get underwayPeerless Djokovic 'on cloud nine'Sean Hannity is desperate for your retweetsNaver, Kakao strive to combat deepfake porn spreading onlineRidiculous news cycle leads Jon Stewart and HBO to cancel their showUS says North Korea behind malware attacks节能补贴调整后首批入围车型公布Elon Musk's AI facility is reportedly operating gas turbines without a permitJapan annihilates Germany 4
- ·广州市白云区供销联社携手6所院校15支队伍,加力提速推进“百千万工程”
- ·Neymar breaks Pele's record
- ·Afghanistan tend to lose track in 50 over games
- ·'The dark shadows' are back [PHOTOS]
- ·The local version of Project 2025 is already causing devastation.
- ·NK presses S. Korea to shift inter
- ·N. Korea's nominal head of state to attend Russia World Cup
- ·Voeller honest about scope of Germany rebuild
- ·18 Slightly Submerged Architectural Wonders
- ·“石棉黄果柑”喜获地理标志证明商标
- ·The luxury shopping list: 8 high
- ·Ten Hag unsure about Sancho’s future
- ·21 College and University Museums
- ·Laura Dern's new 'Star Wars' character looks ready for the Hunger Games
- ·Koreans heading to Philippines drop amid military rule, shooting attack
- ·节能补贴调整后首批入围车型公布
- ·蒙顶山茶有了专属茶器
- ·“石棉黄果柑”喜获地理标志证明商标
- ·Afghanistan tend to lose track in 50 over games
- ·Huawei's new foldable phone costs $2,700—and doesn't come with Google apps
- ·Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
- ·IFTTT wants to connect all those companies and their connected devices
- ·US missile defense chief expresses 'great concern' about NK missile development
- ·Afghanistan tend to lose track in 50 over games
- ·Blinken condemns Russia
- ·Japan annihilates Germany 4
- ·厚植精神文明沃土 培树司法文明新风
- ·IFTTT wants to connect all those companies and their connected devices
- ·在湛江吴川,经营10万+用户的相亲生意
- ·Japan annihilates Germany 4
- ·高温难耐,工会驿站化身“清凉小屋”
- ·Peerless Djokovic 'on cloud nine'
- ·Japan annihilates Germany 4
- ·Ridiculous news cycle leads Jon Stewart and HBO to cancel their show
- ·Game Plan
- ·Sean Hannity is desperate for your retweets