Public land ownership tax: Solution to inequality or infringement of rights?
时间:2024-09-23 08:17:14 来源:泸州新闻网
Lee’s envisioned tax is similar to the nation’s comprehensive real estate holding tax, which is levied on high-priced real estate. But Lee hopes to impose taxes on all land, meaning homeowners would pay taxes on the land their homes occupy.
This tax could bring in about 50 trillion won ($42 billion) on an annual basis, Lee has said. He plans to use the money to bankroll his universal basic income project.
Lee believes the tax would curb real estate speculation, counter asset polarization and minimize tax resistance. According to Lee, about 80 percent to 90 percent of citizens stand to benefit from the proposed tax system.
He came up with the plan during the Democratic Party’s primary race ahead of the 2017 presidential election and has consistently advocated for it ever since.
During his tenure as governor of Gyeonggi Province, he once said, “If the central government feels burdened by introducing it nationwide, allow local governments to establish it as a local tax.”
In response to critics who called the proposed tax an infringement of property rights, Lee said on Facebook on Monday, “If you object to the tax for fear of losing money when you don’t even belong to the top 10 percent of landholders, you are a fool manipulated by malicious media and corrupt political forces.”
Some experts share Lee’s view that social inequality is widening due to soaring housing prices and real estate speculation.
Han Moon-do, a professor at Yonsei University’s graduate school of political science, said, “The direction of the land ownership tax is something we should consider in the mid- to long term.
“Over the past decades, wages and interest have not risen much, but only land prices have surged,” he said, adding this needs to be addressed in some way.
According to the local civic group the Citizens’ Coalition for Economic Justice in December 2019, private land prices had more than quadrupled since 1999, resulting in 6,600 trillion won in unearned income for a few. Seventy percent of the population does not own land. The figure was 14 times higher than total wage increases during the same 20-year period.
But Han says the plan should not be executed in a rush and would require good communication and persuasion.
“As he hurriedly made a political pledge and tied it with basic income, it seems to be populism and draws backlash from many,” he said.
Park Sun-koo, chief of the Korea Research Institute for Construction Policy’s economics and finance research division, agreed that the concept should be pondered in the long term.
South Korea’s widening inequality was caused by disparities in assets, not income, he said. According to OECD data, the level of income equality in South Korea is similar to levels seen among other member nations, but uneven wealth distribution is a growing problem here.
“It is necessary to ponder over reorganizing the nation’s tax structure as Korean society ages and expenditures continue to increase, but revenues are limited,” he said.
Many, however, oppose Lee’s promise.
Son Jae-young, a professor at Konkuk University’s Graduate School of Real Estate Studies, said such a tax would infringe on private property rights.
“The reason South Korea grows economically and North Korea cannot hinges on whether a country protects private property rights,” Son said. “Belittling private property rights can, in the end, hurt the nation’s economic growth.”
He does not believe the real estate issue is responsible for social inequality.
“Millions of Koreans became middle-income people after becoming homeowners. And as the (asset) prices go up, they can stably retain their middle-class status,” he said.
He also doubts whether the proposed tax could generate 50 trillion won in tax revenue.
“Will they levy it on agricultural land? What about a person with one house? Companies that run factories and small business owners?” Son asked.
“If they exclude taxes for this and that reason, actually there are not many left to levy it on,” he said.
Another presidential candidate, former Deputy Prime Minister Kim Dong-yeon, said Tuesday, “The idea of collecting taxes from landowners and distributing the money equally to the people is a very dangerous idea.”
“Basic income is something we should talk about when jobs are reduced due to robots or artificial intelligence in the future,” he added. “It is not money that is distributed like universal welfare or disaster support funds or disaster support funds.”
He said it would draw considerable tax resistance from individuals who own land for residential purposes, not for speculation purposes.
-
让法治建设成效更加可感可及Park requests 15 more witnesses at impeachment trialOsasuna earn narrow advantage over AthleticArsenal need to be more unpredictable: Arteta“精致小春姐”顾春芳:华丽白西装、镶钻水晶拖鞋,带来新兴凉果No.1凝聚力量,共襄善举!揭西县举行“6·30”助力乡村振兴活动捐赠仪式Djokovic to learn Indian Wells fate MondaySouth Korea's technological superiority challenged by North Korea's cyberattacksPressure boost squeezes out more hydrogen from artificial leavesTwitter finally finds a way to silence Piers Morgan — and for a good cause
相关内容
- ·The Composer Has No Clothes
- ·Flight electronics ban will separate passengers from their private data
- ·严打“黑车”确保道路运输安全
- ·Incognito Mode is coming to Google Maps
- ·CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
- ·'Insanity goes on' as Union Berlin meet Bayern
- ·Maine voters double down on facial recognition ban in win for privacy
- ·In a first for U.S., this bumblebee is now officially 'endangered'
- ·Expanded police surveillance will get us “broken windows” on steroids.
- ·Make a plan: How getting out the vote has become 2020's biggest viral challenge
- ·Crooks named Canada Soccer acting president
- ·HTC's new, cheaper blockchain phone will run a full Bitcoin node
- ·Revolutionary grid
- ·'Insanity goes on' as Union Berlin meet Bayern
- ·落实责任严格考核 推进农村公路管理养护工作
- ·'Insanity goes on' as Union Berlin meet Bayern
最新内容
- ·Table tennis star Shin Yu
- ·Osasuna earn narrow advantage over Athletic
- ·Hockey player Shahida among victims of migrant boat tragedy
- ·Meet the Ethiopian community getting access to clean water for the first time
- ·Apple Intelligence is now a little easier to get outside the U.S.
- ·In a first for U.S., this bumblebee is now officially 'endangered'
- ·兴农评丨山区县中高考“逆袭”,他们的答卷振奋人心
- ·How to watch Google I/O 2019 keynote and what to expect
- ·CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
- ·Arsenal need to be more unpredictable: Arteta
推荐内容
热点内容
- ·NYT mini crossword answers for August 29
- ·Crooks named Canada Soccer acting president
- ·市委宣讲团将赴县区宣讲十七届五中全会精神
- ·Twitter finally finds a way to silence Piers Morgan — and for a good cause
- ·Trump trials: Jack Smith is reportedly reconsidering his strategy.
- ·'This is fine' Halloween decoration perfectly nails 2020
- ·Schwarz pips Odermatt in California giant slalom
- ·Osasuna earn narrow advantage over Athletic
- ·17 Spectacular Outdoor Staircases
- ·US urges N. Korea to refrain from raising tensions after resumption of reactor operations