Rising NK threats raise questions over US policy efficacy
U.S. President Joe Biden delivers a prime-time address to the nation about his approaches to the conflict between Israel and Hamas, humanitarian assistance in Gaza and continued support for Ukraine in their war with Russia, from the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, U.S., Oct. 19. Reuters-Yonhap
North Korea's bellicose rhetoric, persistent weapons tests and pursuit of sturdier military ties with Russia are raising questions over whether it is time for the United States to recalibrate its policy and take a more creative approach.
After taking office in early 2021, the Joe Biden administration unveiled a "calibrated, practical" approach to Pyongyang, put out diplomatic feelers to the intransigent regime and emphasized its readiness to engage in dialogue "anywhere, anytime without preconditions."
But its approach has been hamstrung by the North's insular stance in the midst of COVID-19, its deepening distrust towards South Korea and the U.S., and America's heavy focus on handling more urgent geopolitical challenges, including Russia's war in Ukraine, observers said.
Calls for Washington to pay more heed to evolving North Korean threats have risen as North Korean leader Kim Jong-un's rhetoric against Seoul and his regime's tests of apparent nuclear weapon delivery platforms raised the specter of potential armed conflict on the Korean Peninsula.
Concerns have also been deepening over the dwindling space for diplomatic engagement with the North as Pyongyang has been turning to its traditional partners, Russia and China, in a way that has lessened its appetite for diplomacy with the U.S. or the South.
The Biden administration is credited with strengthening deterrence efforts with Seoul and Tokyo and tightening the enforcement of U.N. Security Council resolutions, but North Korean threats have continued unabated.
"It's unfortunate the U.S. government doesn't seem to have any creative North Korea policy besides finger wagging," Josh Rogin, a columnist, wrote in an op-ed on The Washington Post published Thursday. "The Biden administration has bolstered ties with (and between) Japan and South Korea, but alliance management is hardly sufficient."
This photo, captured from North Korea's Central TV, Jan. 29, shows North Korean leader Kim Jong-un inspecting the North's test-firing of the new Pulhwasal-3-31 strategic cruise missile from a submarine the previous day. Yonhap
At the start of the Biden administration, questions lingered over whether its approach toward the North would be a replica of a "strategic patience" approach that commentators said was pursued by the former Barack Obama administration.
Strategic patience refers to the U.S. waiting patiently until the North shifts towards denuclearization while heaping pressure on it through sanctions, diplomatic isolation and other measures.
The Biden administration's repeated dialogue overtures to the North under the "no-hostile-intent" mantra helped ease worries about the potential revival of a strategic patience approach, but concerns have reemerged amid a recent rise in tensions on the peninsula.
"I think the Biden administration's approach is inadequate because it hasn't adjusted to address North Korea's new posture, and it has already demonstrated itself ineffective in changing North Korea's behavior," Frank Aum, a senior expert at the United States Institute of Peace, told Yonhap News via email.
"Of course, the Biden administration argues that it is engaging seriously, beyond just rhetoric, by reaching out numerous times to North Korea to engage but to no avail."
Aum described the Biden administration's stance on the North as one similar to the Obama administration's second-term "pressure-based" approach that "used diplomatic isolation, economic sanctions and military deterrence measures."
During Obama's first White House term from 2009-2012, his administration sought to engage with the North -- an endeavor that led to the 2012 "Leap Day" deal under which the U.S. agreed to offer nutritional aid in return for Pyongyang's moratorium on nuclear and missile tests. But his policy took a shift after the deal broke down due to the North's subsequent rocket launch.
"Biden is maintaining the pressure-based approach, but he is open to talks 'without preconditions,'" Aum said. "But of course, there are preconditions in Biden's approach -- i.e., denuclearization has to be on the agenda, and talks have to start at the working level to demonstrate that North Korea is serious -- and North Korea is not interested in meeting those preconditions."
Commenting on Biden's approach to the North compared with Obama's formula, Patrick Cronin, Asia-Pacific security chair at the Hudson Institute, took note of changes in the security, political, and geostrategic landscapes in recent years.
Those changes involve Washington's navigation through a change from the former liberal South Korean government to the current conservative one, and ascendant competition with China and Russia, which Cronin said keeps North Korea as a "lower priority."
Against the backdrop of growing instability in the Middle East and other policy headaches, the Biden administration appears to have focused largely on "managing the status quo" when it comes to North Korea, Nam Chang-hee, political science professor at Inha University, said.
"The U.S. does not want to see a major clash on the peninsula flare up," Nam said. "And North Korea may have expectations for how things will unfold should former President Donald Trump return to the White House."
Nam was referring to Trump's presidency during which the former president sought leader-to-leader diplomacy with the North Korean leader, which led to three in-person meetings between them though serious negotiations stalled following their no-deal summit in Hanoi in 2019.
While the rise in tensions on the peninsula has drawn renewed attention to the U.S.' policy approach forward, views on whether tension would spiral into a bigger conflict varied.
The debate on the possibility of war picked up pace after Robert Carlin, a former North Korea analyst at the Central Intelligence Agency, and Siegfried Hecker, a renowned American nuclear scientist, recently said they believe the North Korean leader has decided to "go to war."
"That may sound overly dramatic, but we believe that, like his grandfather in 1950, Kim Jong-un has made a strategic decision to go to war," they said in a joint contribution to 38 North, a U.S. website devoted to analysis about North Korea.
But others differed.
"I think there are many rungs to the escalation ladder that North Korea could climb short of war," Victor Cha, senior vice president for Asia and Korea Chair at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said.
"I would expect they would do that before going to all-out war. Having said that 2024 will be a year of many North Korean military demonstrations/ provocations," he added.
To chart a path for de-escalation at a minimum, experts called for more proactive diplomatic efforts.
"Instead of just preparing militarily, the U.S. and ROK should shift their approach so that they emphasize diplomacy," Aum said. "Right now, the alliance has a very narrow focus on deterrence and is ignoring all the diplomatic tools in their toolkit."
ROK stands for South Korea's official name, the Republic of Korea. (Yonhap)
-
Spate of defections show Kim Jong鎼缓鍏泭鐢熸€佸湀 娴峰皵甯屾湜灏忓鎻村缓鎶曞叆绱瓒呬竴浜垮厓平安人寿青岛分公司:开展“智慧生活 与书共享”世界读书日活动明目标 强举措 促消费 重统筹科创筑梦树立远大志向 蓄势赋能培养科技人才身为首家战略合作行 招行怎样助力全国“电子健康卡”战略实施?国家市场监管总局:6·18网络促销不得先涨价再打折下腹剧痛莫轻视 及时就医最关键Police bust crypto scammer who received plastic surgery to evade arrest事关所有人的钱包!个税法第七次大修 这些事情你该知道
下一篇:科创筑梦树立远大志向 蓄势赋能培养科技人才
- ·Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- ·有一种幸福,叫“生活在雅安”
- ·招商银行青岛分行:闪电贷“快闪”活动重磅来袭
- ·专家现场分享病例 助力诊疗水平提升
- ·The Measurers
- ·金融科技赋能用户体验 招商银行“再进化”
- ·下腹剧痛莫轻视 及时就医最关键
- ·青岛诞生首家新三板转板上市公司
- ·How to watch 'Kinds of Kindness': When is it streaming?
- ·招行青岛秦岭路支行成功举办基础客群推介会
- ·提高工作质量 切实服务群众
- ·下腹剧痛莫轻视 及时就医最关键
- ·13 Places to Find Little Legends and Compact Cryptids
- ·交通银行青岛市南一支行:用心服务为核心,不断提升软实力
- ·青岛领跑山东最具价值品牌企业榜单 18家企业上榜百强
- ·金融科技赋能用户体验 招商银行“再进化”
- ·10 Big Misconceptions About Computer Hardware
- ·厅堂改造,只因您而变
- ·中国平安与赛诺菲强强联手 用智慧医疗助力“健康中国”
- ·帮扶措施多样化 就业扶贫全覆盖
- ·Cicadas love to land on people. Experts explain why.
- ·追着阳光走 在雅安过一个暖和的冬天
- ·金融科技赋能用户体验 招商银行“再进化”
- ·营造人居舒适环境 打造绿美城市形象
- ·How much for Oasis tickets? Fans joke about splurging on reunion shows
- ·海关“智慧监管”让自动化码头更快、更强