The most lawless court in the country won’t let Biden vaccinate his own workforce.
On Thursday, the 5thU.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a block on President Joe Biden’s vaccine mandate for executive branch employees. The mandate has been on hold since January 2022, when Judge Jeffrey Vincent Brown issued a nationwide injunction freezing it. Brown, a Donald Trump appointee, is one of several far-right Texas judges handing out sweeping injunctions to conservative plaintiffs against the Biden administration; collectively, these judges have halted dozens of executive policies, effectively subjecting the president’s every move to a near-instant judicial veto.
In the Slate Plus bonus segment of this week’s Amicus, Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern talked about the 5thCircuit’s decision and its implication for Biden’s ability to exercise basic presidential powers. Their conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
Dahlia Lithwick: This week, we’ve got another instance of a nationwide injunction and judge-shopping, this one surrounding President Biden’s vaccine mandate for executive branch employees. Can you walk us through the all-too-familiar pattern here?
Mark Joseph Stern:So, this is a case challenging President Joe Biden’s mandate that all executive branch employees obtain a vaccine against COVID-19. Of course, the Supreme Court has blocked the vaccine mandate that applied to private employers. But this is something different: This is about the president’s own workforce. And you might think, ‘well, the president is the head of the executive branch.’ The Supreme Court has said many times that “all executive power” is vested in him, endorsing the “unitary executive” theory. And so you would expect, perhaps, that the president could make some basic decisions about his workforce, including that they be vaccinated so they are less likely to contract and pass on COVID.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAnd yet, when this mandate came down, anti-vax plaintiffs started shopping around in the courts to try to get a nationwide injunction against it. They went to 12different district courts and lost in all 12 of them. Then they went to a thirteenth court to ensure they’d pull a Trump judge, Jeffrey Vincent Brown. Of course, Brown then issued a nationwide injunction blocking the vaccine mandate for the entire executive workforce—not just for the plaintiffs in the case, but everybody under the sun who works for the executive branch.
The case goes up to a panel of the 5thCircuit, which says the judge got it wrong. Why? There is a federal law, the Civil Service Reform Act, that requires grievances raised by executive branch employees to go through this very complex administrative process. For decades, the rule has been that executive branch employees have to exhaust their administrative remedies before going to court. And even if they get fired in the meantime, their remedy in court is backpay and reinstatement. They do not get to go to a federal court right upfront and demand an injunction, let alone a nationwide injunction.
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- Sure Sounds Like the Supreme Court Is About to Give Trump a Big Win!
- A Supreme Court Justice Gave Us Alarming New Evidence That He’s Living in MAGA World
- Ten Years Ago, His Book About Civilizational Collapse Got Unexpectedly Popular. He’s Back With a Little Bit of Hope.
- The Anti-Defamation League Has Become a Threat to Jewish Safety
But surprise, surprise: The full 5thCircuit decides to rehear the case. And on Thursday, it ruled that, actually, there is a special, secret exception to the Civil Service Reform Act that says that it doesn’t apply when the president tries to make his employees undergo an “irreversible medical decision.” So the plaintiffs get to skip over all of those administrative procedures and ignore this federal law that governs the rules for everybody else. The court devoted two sentences to the merits of this case, which are essentially: “We substantially agree with the district court’s decision, and we do not need to repeat its analysis here.” That’s how the lawless arsonists on the fightin’ 5thCircuit operate.
Never underestimate the arsonists, Mark
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementSo we now have this nationwide injunction upheld by the 5thCircuit against the president of the United States, barring him from protecting his own workforce against COVID—on the grounds that the 5thCircuit thinks that this random district court judge got it right and those other twelve, they got it wrong and we don’t need to worry about them.
It’s funny, when you think about the delivery of justice at this moment. It’s like: You put your quarter in the slot machine knowing that you can get exactly the judge you want, the way you might get a Snickers bar from a vending machine. Then you’re going to have the 5th Circuit say “Oh, but it’s Snickers bar! We win.” It’s just amazing, and antithetical to way this is all meant to work.
Tweet Share Share Comment- ·World's first green ammonia plant is now open for business
- ·小伙水潭溺水 命悬一线 老人及时营救 化险为夷
- ·合理用水不浪费 崇尚节约风尚浓
- ·“至圣孔子礼乐团”亮相青岛
- ·高燃!哨响表停赛不止,2024广东“村BA”开赛在即,一分钟带你重温高光瞬间。
- ·八旬老人患热射病晕倒 多学科全力救治保平安
- ·探索青岛影视发展方向影视沙龙暨《绝地出击》发布会召开
- ·创新争先锋丨青岛移动:走“实”出“新”,为社会治理智造强市增添新动能
- ·If aliens harnessed solar power, could we detect them? NASA investigated.
- ·梁晓声|爱阅读的人 一生将是幸福的
- ·琼州海峡拥堵!海南农产品价格暴跌
- ·守护你的钱袋子!平安人寿青岛分公司送防非知识进网点 筑牢防非安全墙
- ·PS5 Pro: It looks like a sketch of the design just leaked
- ·关注骨关节健康 切实服务广大病患
- ·青岛移动“移动全千兆·智享云生活”智慧家庭产业联盟云端论坛成功举行
- ·琼州海峡拥堵!海南农产品价格暴跌
- ·Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
- ·CCOR帆船赛4月27日上演
- ·最全游玩攻略!2月23
- ·鏈懆鏈紝闈掑矝鍥介檯浼氳涓績灏嗕妇鍔炰竴鍦烘枃鍖栫洓瀹確涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- ·水产品占“四席”!广州南沙十个农产品上榜“国字号”
- ·青岛市城市冰雪灾害Ⅲ级应急响应凌晨启动
- ·两年零九个月! 77岁老太绣出22米清明上河图
- ·春风化雨润心田 文明新风遍雅州
- ·Best smartphone deal: Google Pixel 8a on sale for $449 at Amazon
- ·鐩哥害鐏靛北婀 娆㈣仛鏄熷厜宀沖涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- ·NASA says Earth just had the hottest day ever recorded
- ·两年零九个月! 77岁老太绣出22米清明上河图
- ·首次饰演武侠片中的历史人物 青岛演员文俊珽用“尊重历史”刻画角色
- ·创新争先锋丨青岛移动:走“实”出“新”,为社会治理智造强市增添新动能
- ·PS5 Pro: It looks like a sketch of the design just leaked
- ·琼州海峡拥堵!海南农产品价格暴跌
- ·青岛市城市冰雪灾害Ⅲ级应急响应凌晨启动
- ·新年,从一只鸡开始丨故乡的肉味
- ·Weather update for second Pak vs Ban second Test match day one
- ·青岛东方影都闪耀第23届香港国际影视展