Why are people leaving Substack?
Substack, the popular newsletter publishing platform toting millions of subscribers, is at the center of a user quagmire in 2024: Should we stay or should we go?
In a recent article by The Atlantic, the platform was called a "ticking time bomb" of content moderation issues, which have prompted several prominent blogs and writers to publish scathing indictments of the site before ceremoniously leaving the platform.
The company has faced other battles in the last year as well, including a brief feud with Elon Musk-owned X/Twitter. So why are users ushering in the new year by exiting the site now?
SEE ALSO:Artifact, the AI news app created by Instagram's founders, is shutting downUsers demand content moderation and accountability
In Nov. 2023, the Atlanticpublished an investigation into growing networks of white nationalists hosting alt-right and neo-Nazi blogs on Substack. Seemingly against terms of service that ban hate on the platform, the frequently antisemitic blogs were generating consistent revenue for both the publishers and Substack itself, which takes a portion of subscription revenue.
In response, hundreds of writers issued an open letter to Substack asking for an explanation. Later, another group of writers and fans published a letter in support of subscriber freedom and opposing increased content moderation.
On Dec. 21, Substack co-founder Hamish McKenzie uploaded a blog post responding to outcries over "fringe accounts," saying: "I just want to make it clear that we don’t like Nazis either — we wish no-one held those views. But some people do hold those and other extreme views. Given that, we don't think that censorship (including through demonetizing publications) makes the problem go away — in fact, it makes it worse."
As of January, Substack had removed only a few of the offending blogs pointed out by fellow users. Thus rested an age-old internet question: How far should a platform — or "content host," in this instance — intervene in its user base, and what kind of protection does it owe those scrolling its site?
Casey Newton, creator of the Silicon Valley news blog Platformer, announced on Jan. 11 that the blog would be leaving Substack due to the ongoing content moderation issues and the lackluster response of Substack officials to removing alt-right content. The post (subhead: "We’ve seen this movie before — and we won’t stick around to watch it play out.") also details his own effort to have antisemitic blogs removed from the site.
"As all of this unfolded, I spoke twice with Substack’s co-founders. And while they asked that those conversations be off the record, my understanding from our conversations — based on material they had shared with me in writing — was that in the future they would regard explicitly Nazi and pro-Holocaust material to be a violation of their existing policies," Newton described of his and fellow Substack publishers' efforts. "But on Tuesday, when I wrote my story about the company’s decision to remove five publications, that language was missing from their statement. Instead, the company framed the entire discussion as having been about the handful of publications I had sent them for review."
Other newsletter publishers, including popular writer Ryan Broderick, were similarly disappointed in the response. In his announcement, Broderick wrote that Substack "has a habit of turning these, frankly, fairly basic trust and safety problems into weird political fights that drag on for weeks."
"Substack has faced occasional controversies over its laissez-faire approach to content moderation," Newton explained. "The platform hosts a wide range of material I find distasteful and offensive. But for a time, the distribution of that material was limited to those who had signed up to receive it. In that respect, I did not view the decision to host Platformer on Substack as being substantially different from hosting it on, for example, GoDaddy. Substack’s aspirations now go far beyond web hosting."
Pure web hosting has fallen by the wayside
In addition to the questionable content decisions of Substack leads, many posting on the site have shared a wariness of the platform's evolving mission and its impact on independent writers, a shift from the site's original marketing as an ambiguously defined content hosting site without the ambition of mainstream publishers and social media sites.
But in April 2023, Substack launched its Notes feature, a "Twitter dupe" that allows Substack subscribers and writers to share posts, links, snippets, you name it, in a streamlined feed mirroring the X timeline. "Notes also marks the next step in our efforts to build our subscription network — one that puts writers and readers in charge, rewards great work with money, and protects the free press and free speech," Substack wrote in a blog post at the time.
Related Stories
- Meta's moderation failures incite hate and human rights abuses, according to Amnesty International
- Most users on X never see Community Notes correcting misinformation
- X / Twitter lets Israel-Gaza hate speech spread, new study finds — and these users are the culprits
- Elon Musk still plans to turn X / Twitter into a PayPal dupe
Meanwhile, the platform was under careful watch from financial reporters, following the revelation of the platform's 2020-2021 financial statements (the numbers were grim). Substack had recently launched a site-wide crowdfunding campaign, as well, generating more than $7 million from users.
Some writers note that they feel the broad push for "the Substack network" — referring to the growing connections between its community of writers, subscription recommendations, and new features like Notes — runs counter to the organic discovery and subscription models that enticed them to join initially.
This all signaled to many that the hands-off, pure content hosting goal of the platform was shifting, pushing the site closer to the realm of an advertising social media company instead of an avenue for independent publishing, fostering small communities of self-moderated readers and writers.
As Newton warned in his departure post, Substack:
"touts the value of its network of publications as a primary reason to use its product, and has built several tools to promote that network. It encourages writers to recommend other Substack publications. It sends out a weekly digest of publications for readers to consider subscribing to. And last year it launched a Twitter-like social network called Notes that highlights posts from around the network, regardless of whether you follow those writers or not. Not all of you use these features. Some of you might not have seen them. But I can speak to their effectiveness: In 2023, we added more than 70,000 free subscribers. While I would love to credit that growth exclusively to our journalism and analysis, I believe we have seen firsthand how quickly and aggressively tools like these can grow a publication. And if Substack can grow a publication like ours that quickly, it can grow other kinds of publications, too."
Where are people turning to now?
Substack remains a popular site for writers, cultural commenters, film critics, and even journalists, but disenchanted users are seeking out alternatives. Some are turning toward other hosting sites like Ghost and Beehiiv, the Atlanticreports.
The decision is in your hands.
-
'Hyundai Way': Auto giant's W121tr plan aims to seize mobility market leadBlinken, Austin to visit Korea after flying to JapanElon Musk tells employees smoking weed with Joe Rogan was 'not wise'强化政治引领创新活动载体 扩大机关党建工作影响力Families of S. Korean detainees in NK appeal to embassies for supportS. Korea considers joining Quad Plus to steer US toward talks with N. Korea: policy adviserOnline risk predictor claims to estimate chance of developing melanoma[INTERVIEW] 'Impact of scrapping GSOMIA will hit Korea harder'It's Unnecessary But, AMD Is Basically Lying About CPU PerformanceTrump lawyer sends cease
- ·Pakistan Cricket at crossroads after shock defeat at Pindi
- ·North Korea fires unidentified projectiles toward East Sea
- ·S. Korea agrees to pay 13.9% more from 2019 to host US troops
- ·201万亩!广东全面完成今年林分优化提升年度任务
- ·Which iPad Model Is Right for You?
- ·Salma Hayek is firmly against Barbie's Frida Kahlo doll
- ·App Store scammers are making thousands of dollars by exploiting TouchID
- ·滨江西路附属设施即将完善
- ·Echo Dot (5th gen) deal — get it for $29.99 at Amazon
- ·三类惠农金融产品 看看哪一个适合你?
- ·27 times Ricky Gervais tweeted about his partner Jane
- ·导演曹晓宁:推动文化润疆,要有能留下、能流通、能流传的精品力作
- ·Google Search tries new tactics for limiting explicit deepfakes
- ·Dennis Rodman, who hangs with Trump and Kim, says Korea peace deal 'could still work'
- ·Cops struggle to pull over allegedly drunk, sleeping Tesla driver
- ·Players, fans will both suffer from too much football: Lewa
- ·50 Places to Eat and Drink Before You Die
- ·滨江西路附属设施即将完善
- ·碧峰峡有新宠 身材只有两个巴掌大
- ·Australian heroes brave floodwaters to save a giant spider
- ·阳江村K开麦,阳西3人晋级!
- ·Earth's winds have picked up again, after decades of slowing
- ·UN blames Facebook for spreading hatred about Rohingya in Myanmar
- ·201万亩!广东全面完成今年林分优化提升年度任务
- ·Top 10 Tech Pranks
- ·Trump’s historic unpopularity is the defining characteristic of his presidency.
- ·NCT member Taeil leaves band over sexual offense allegations
- ·Cryptocurrency startup wants to 'pay' you to watch porn, but there's a catch
- ·Cryptocurrency startup wants to 'pay' you to watch porn, but there's a catch
- ·Bannon antics reportedly alienate his benefactor, GOP superdonor Rebekah Mercer.
- ·50 Years Later: The Revolutionary 8008 Microprocessor
- ·These shockingly racist juror statements don’t matter to the Supreme Court’s conservatives.
- ·Tom Brady challenged to a beer chugging contest by Stephen Colbert
- ·Inside Quinn, a new site for audio erotica
- ·Google Gemini now allows AI
- ·广东推广“林长+”协作机制,激活绿美新动能