The Champions League has become a thorn in Guardiola's side
With the millions they have invested in top players and with the most respected coach of his generation in charge, Manchester City should be doing much better than going out of the Champions League in the last eight.
But after their shock 3-1 defeat by Olympique Lyonnais on Saturday that is exactly what City have done in the last three years.
Guardiola was brought into the club, by their Abu Dhabi based owner Sheikh Mansour, after his predecessor as manager, Chilean Manuel Pellegrini had taken the club to the semi-finals of the Champions League, while also winning the Premier League title.
And while Guardiola has brought two Premier League titles, smashed records and produced some of the most glorious football the club's fans have ever seen -- European success remains elusive to his team.
Clearly it irritates the Spaniard greatly, indeed at times he appears almost obsessed with the competition.
Throughout this season, Guardiola has frequently referred to the Champions League, without prompting, when asked questions about the domestic campaign.
There is a noticeably different demeanour to Guardiola in the build-up to Champions League games, he is edgier, even in the group stage where he has a tendency to exaggerate the quality of relatively modest opponents.
The assumption had always been that City, as relative newcomers to the European elite, just needed to adjust to the different demands that the Champions League can place on a team.
"One day we will break this gap to the semis," he said after Saturday's loss.
"The team over last few years deserve it. Maybe one day we'll break this gap."
But now questions are being asked of Guardiola himself and surprisingly for a man considered to be a master tactician, of his team selection and formation.
City had looked a mature, top European team while beating 13-times winners Real Madrid home and away in the previous round.
But Guardiola changed the winning formula from that game, replacing the attacking midfielder Phil Foden with an extra defender in 19-year-old Eric Garcia.
It was an unexpected decision. Clearly Guardiola felt that he needed to neutralise a Lyon attack that can often take the form of a trident but it quickly became apparent that the move had handed the French side the initiative in midfield and City were unable to dominate in their usual manner.
CHASING THE MATCH
When he belatedly took off defender Fernandinho for winger Riyad Mahrez, in the 56th minute, City's attacking threat increased significantly and 13 minutes later they drew level.
Guardiola's tactics don't explain how his side allowed a simple ball over the top to lead to Moussa Dembele's goal to make it 2-1, nor do they have anything to do with Raheem Sterling then missing an absolute sitter from close range.
The third goal came with City desperately chasing the match in search of a leveller but there still remains the question of whether Guardiola had simply over-complicated the team's task.
Former England winger Chris Waddle, who played in France with Olympique Marseille, reaching the final of the European Cup in 1991, had no doubts that Guardiola should have allowed City to play their normal way.
"They didn't trouble them enough, it needed a David Silva playing between the gaps. They wouldn't have liked playing against Phil Foden tonight," he said.
"Pep Guardiola has to put his hands up tonight and say I got it wrong."
Lyon coach Rudi Garcia added to the debate with his assertion that his team had "won the tactical battle".
But Guardiola was dismissive of that notion.
"In this competition the tactics are not the most important thing," Guardiola told a news conference.
"They (Lyon) are so fast and our central defenders are not so quick so I didn't want to leave them two versus two.
"We worked for three days on this, we discussed it and we reviewed this and when you play like we did in the last 20 minutes it shows the system is not the problem."
But the fact remains that a City team which beat Zinedine Zidane's Real were good enough to beat Lyon and didn't.
Working out exactly why, will be something that Guardiola is now likely to deeply ponder for many months.
-
13 Places to Find Little Legends and Compact CryptidsArgentina fans greet Messi's arrivalWorkers in states quick to reopen would lose unemployment benefits if too fearful to return yet.从鲜龙眼到桂圆肉,高州储良龙眼凭啥从夏天火到秋天?Swifties for Kamala raises over $100,000 in donations for Harris campaignNASA's Artemis spacecraft will whip around the moon over 42 days12 best and funniest tweets of the weekUndocumented workers are shut out of the stimulus.Sinner vs. Michelsen 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for freeSeoul to open bank branches in North Korea only after sanctions are lifted
- ·Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
- ·How NYC confused everyone over its not
- ·Senate Republicans contradict Trump on Russian interference.
- ·Using a PlayStation 4 Controller with Your PC
- ·Pressure boost squeezes out more hydrogen from artificial leaves
- ·Ministry to inject W11.2tr into higher, lifelong education
- ·What Are the Best CCleaner Alternatives?
- ·What is skin cycling? A step
- ·'Metaphor: ReFantazio' hands
- ·Barcelona continues to ramp up efforts to increase city’s digital capacity
- ·How to watch Samsung's Galaxy Unpacked 2021: foldable phone edition
- ·Firefighters sue interior minister over Halloween crowd crush
- ·New image shows the North Star is changing. And it has spots.
- ·Firefighters sue interior minister over Halloween crowd crush
- ·Anger over list of Itaewon tragedy victims
- ·营造良好社会氛围 推动全市创业工作再上新台阶
- ·Pakistan to host South Africa before ICC Women’s T20 World Cup
- ·The Supreme Court holds livestreamed arguments for the first time in history.
- ·Trump goes on angry anti
- ·Defense chiefs of S. Korea, Australia discuss bilateral security cooperation
- ·The Wonderful World of Christmas Trees
- ·Wise life advice from a 5
- ·立足“造血”扶贫 开拓增收新路
- ·DeFi platform begs hackers to return $600 million in stolen crypto
- ·Sinkhole swallows up car, injuring 2 in Seoul
- ·Barcelona continues to ramp up efforts to increase city’s digital capacity
- ·I went to an offline dating event for singles. Here's how it went.
- ·Can the House work from home?
- ·TikTok's 'Euphoria' High trend heightens the HBO teen drama's absurd fashion
- ·Argentina fans greet Messi's arrival
- ·Ruling bloc divided on foreign nannies' pay
- ·Apple warns iPhone and Mac owners of vulnerability, and it's update time
- ·Ministry to inject W11.2tr into higher, lifelong education
- ·Anger over list of Itaewon tragedy victims
- ·Klarna CEO reveals plan to reduce workforce by 50% and replace it with AI
- ·American Airlines now offers free inflight access to TikTok