Moon's proposal to end Korean War faces feasibility questions
时间:2024-09-23 05:18:54 来源:泸州新闻网
President Moon Jae-in addresses the 76th session of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, Tuesday (EST). Yonhap |
Unresponsive Pyongyang, Washington-Beijing rivalry stymie talks
By Nam Hyun-woo
President Moon Jae-in once again renewed his call for a formal end to the 1950-53 Korean War in an effort to bring peace to the Korean Peninsula, but the feasibility of his proposal is questionable, given the state of relations between the two Koreas and the U.S.
During a speech at the 76th session of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, Tuesday (EST), Moon proposed a trilateral or quadrilateral declaration to proclaim a formal end to the Korean War.
The war ended in an armistice signed in 1953 by the U.S.-led United Nations Command, China and North Korea, leaving the two Koreas technically still at war.
"Today, I once again urge the community of nations to mobilize its strengths for the end-of-war declaration on the Korean Peninsula, and propose that the three parties of the two Koreas and the U.S., or the four parties of the two Koreas, the U.S. and China, come together and declare that the war on the Korean Peninsula is over," Moon said.
"When the parties involved in the Korean War stand together and proclaim an end to the war, I believe we can make irreversible progress in denuclearization and usher in an era of complete peace," he added.
Unlike a peace treaty, which requires parliamentary level approval, an end-of-war declaration would be a non-binding political statement, thus an easier step for both Washington and Pyongyang.
Due to the relative ease of signing such a declaration, President Moon has been championing the idea since 2018, when inter-Korean relations were at their best in recent years, saying that it would serve as a gateway to peace on the peninsula. He officially proposed the declaration to the international community during last year's U.N. General Assembly. At the time, he did not clarify who should make the declaration, but this time, he specified that the two Koreas, the U.S. and even China could be involved.
US open to discussion with North Korea on end of war declaration: Pentagon spokesman 2021-09-23 09:47 | North Korea
As the President has now specified which countries could be involved in signing the declaration, this proposal is being interpreted as an attempt to find a breakthrough in the inter-Korean stalemate during his presidency, which will end in May next year.
A missile being launched from a train in an undisclosed location in North Korea is seen in this photo released by North Korea's state-run Korean Central News Agency, Sept. 16. Yonhap |
However, Moon's proposal seems unfeasible, considering that inter-Korean relations are deadlocked with the North seemingly continuing on with its nuclear program, while remaining silent toward repeated calls for talks from South Korea and the U.S.
Recent developments in the missile programs of both Koreas are also against the peace narrative that Moon is pitching. On Sept. 15, the South Korean Navy successfully test-fired a domestically developed, submarine-launched, ballistic missile, while on the same day, North Korea launched a ballistic missile from a train, signs that the two Koreas are trying to show each other their military strength.
The conservative main opposition People Power Party (PPP) criticized Moon's proposal, saying that peace cannot be achieved through a declaration, but must come through North Korea taking action to show its commitment to denuclearization.
"The North fired cruise and ballistic missiles from a train less than 10 days ago," PPP vice spokesperson Kim Yeon-joo said in a written commentary. "This act reveals that the Korean Peninsula's situation has not changed, despite the three inter-Korean summits and two Pyongyang-Washington summits under the Moon government," Kim said, adding that Moon did not mention anything about the North's missile launches during his U.N. speech.
Rep. Tae Yong-ho of the PPP, who is a former North Korean diplomat, also said that an end-of-war declaration should be considered only after North Korea makes a meaningful move towards denuclearization.
"So far this year, North Korea has begun carrying out its nuclear program as planned by restarting its nuclear facilities in Yongbyon and by test-firing ballistic missiles. With North Korea escalating its nuclear threat, an end-of-war declaration will only cause North Korea to misbelieve that it may see the withdrawal of the U.S. Forces Korea from the Korean Peninsula," Tae said.
U.S. President Joe Biden addresses the 76th session of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, Tuesday. Reuters-Yonhap |
Rising tensions between the U.S. and China are also lowering the feasibility of an end-of-war declaration within Moon's presidency, because the Joe Biden administration has been stating that it will not engage in a top-down approach of meeting directly with North Korea leader Kim Jong-un or signing any "grand bargains." Involving China in a quadrilateral, end-of-war declaration is also unlikely, given the intertwined rivalry between Washington and Beijing.
During the U.N. General Assembly, Biden said that the U.S. seeks "concrete progress toward an available plan with tangible commitments that would increase stability on the Korean Peninsula," but did not elaborate further on North Korea issues, showing that Washington's diplomatic interests are currently focused largely on China and Afghanistan.
-
评论丨农事运动会:一场农民的盛会、新农人风采展现的盛会、城乡双向奔赴的盛会部门联动 重拳整治“黑三轮”Donald Trump switched to an iPhone and that call for an Apple boycott seems so far away nowAll Kesha wants for Christmas is for you to hear her new music让法治建设成效更加可感可及新生儿保健:新妈妈 新爸爸们的必修课Emmys 2018: The full list of nominationsElon Musk attacks British diver who called his submarine 'just a PR stunt'科创筑梦树立远大志向 蓄势赋能培养科技人才UNESCO institute for documentary heritage slated to open late 2020 in Cheongju: ministry
相关内容
- ·Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
- ·Congressman proposes banning bitcoin at House hearing
- ·David Daleiden claimed to be an undercover journalist when he investigated Planned Parenthood.
- ·$2,700 gold Nokia phone commemorates Trump and Putin's Helsinki summit
- ·Netanyahu’s Inferno
- ·The tragedy of Antonin Scalia.
- ·In defense of Snapchat, a manifesto
- ·Sacha Baron Cohen got a bunch of GOP congressmen to say arming toddlers is a good idea
- ·雅安市第四人民医院:工娱治疗让患者康复之路充满希望
- ·US says China's failure to enforce sanctions delaying North Korea denuclearization
- ·Twitter's new replies are a total nightmare
- ·Congressman proposes banning bitcoin at House hearing
- ·Wordle today: The answer and hints for August 29
- ·Seoul and Washington analyzing North Korea's new ICBM
- ·Moon seeks to rekindle nuclear talks at Tokyo Olympics
- ·Donald Trump switched to an iPhone and that call for an Apple boycott seems so far away now
最新内容
- ·Military prosecutors indict intel official over leaking 'black agent' info
- ·Japan vows action if S. Korea hurts companies in trade row
- ·Oregon occupier David Fry said some weird stuff.
- ·'Biden may order review of policy on North Korea'
- ·The Future of Tech: The Desktop PC
- ·UNESCO institute for documentary heritage slated to open late 2020 in Cheongju: ministry
- ·ABC Republican debate preview: Donald Trump returns.
- ·美丽新村圆梦 幸福生活启航
- ·Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
- ·A big reason for the Flint water crisis: No democracy there.
推荐内容
热点内容
- ·Wordle today: The answer and hints for August 29
- ·市委农工委 强好农业底座 助推一产发展
- ·Lyft made Mono, a working wearable, to hail rides for April Fools' Day
- ·Twitter just killed the default 'egg' profile photo
- ·Michael Cohen fights Donald Trump at the Supreme Court.
- ·Watch this biker pull a dangerous stunt during the Tour de France
- ·Lyft made Mono, a working wearable, to hail rides for April Fools' Day
- ·Obama calling a last minute meeting to save Obamacare
- ·From Prairie Grasslands to Man
- ·Moon seeks to rekindle nuclear talks at Tokyo Olympics