The new Jan. 6 testimony against Trump will be devastating at trial.
On Sunday, ABC News reported on new evidence now in the hands of special counsel Jack Smith that signals a turning point for the prosecution against Donald Trump. If and when the trial goes forward after Trump’s immunity appeals wrap up, the new evidence will be kryptonite to Trump’s hopes for avoiding a conviction.
Progress toward the trial is currently paused during Trump’s appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Experts like Norm Eisen expect that Trump’s weak appellate claims to immunity and purported protection from double jeopardy are likely to be resolved against him well in time for a trial before the November election.
ABC’s latest reporting describes Smith’s interviews with Trump’s close aides, like Dan Scavino, Trump’s communications guru. The interviews put firmly on record Trump’s statements during the three hours on Jan. 6 when he refused like a petulant child to ask the Capitol invaders to go home.
The powerful reported testimony goes straight to the crucial issue in the case: Did Trump criminally intend to overturn the 2020 election? His newly reported statements would conclusively establish for any reasonable juror that Trump wanted the siege to succeed in stopping Congress from certifying President Joe Biden’s election.
Related From Slate
Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern
The Supreme Court Will Decide if Trump Can Run for President. It’s Not Ready for the Fallout.
Read MoreWe already knew about Trump resisting the entreaties of aides, family, and political allies who begged him, once violence began, to immediately call off the dogs of insurrection. He fiddled for 187 minutes while Rome burned.
So what’s new about the evidence that ABC reported Sunday?
AdvertisementTrump’s reported statements are loaded with cruelty, self-interest, and abandonment of allies. It becomes indisputable that he was using his most violent followers to try to override the voters’ will and keep himself in power.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThe statements that ABC reported are new, in part, because witnesses like Scavino and Mark Meadows, the Trump White House chief of staff, didn’t speak with the House Jan. 6 committee.
Scavino still works for Trump’s campaign. Per ABC, he’s been so close and “so supportive of Trump over the years that … in 2020 … Trump joked that … Scavino was ‘the most powerful man in politics.’ ” That will make his testimony especially compelling.
Scavino has now reportedly confirmed something vital to Smith—that it was Trump and Trump alone who posted his infamous 2:24 p.m. Jan. 6 tweet: “Mike Pence didn’t have the courage to do what should have been done.” The Wall Street Journal has called that tweet “the critical moment” of the siege because it poured truckloads of kerosene onto an already roaring fire inside the Capitol.
AdvertisementScavino reportedly told Smith’s team that Trump only posted the tweet after Scavino left him by himself in the White House dining room, Scavino having failed “to persuade Trump to release a calming statement.” After the posting, multiple aides returned to tell Trump that the tweet was “not what we need.”
Trump reportedly responded, with no concern for the tweet’s inciting effect: “But it’s true.” As Nick Luna, now a former Trump aide, reportedly told investigators, Trump “showed he was ‘capable of allowing harm to come to one of his closest allies’ at the time.” This was Luna’s assessment of Trump’s response to the news that Mike Pence had to be evacuated from the Capitol, which ABC reported was “So what?”
AdvertisementABC also reported that Meadows filled in evidentiary gaps about information we had from public reporting. Meadows reportedly confirmed for Smith that he was present to hear Trump tell then–House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, “I guess these people are more upset about the election than you are.”
AdvertisementMcCarthy, too, had refused to testify before the House Jan. 6 committee. He has never publicly acknowledged that Trump spoke those words to him on Jan. 6, and we don’t know whether he’s told Smith about hearing them.
Popular in News & Politics
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- The Lawyer Defending Idaho’s Abortion Ban Irritated the One Justice He Needed on His Side
- Prosecutors Are Finally Revealing Their Strategy Against Trump
- Why David Pecker’s Testimony Was So Credible
Meadows having done so also corroborates bombshell testimony that the House Jan. 6 committee received from Cassidy Hutchinson, Meadows’ aide—that during the early moments of violence on Jan. 6, she heard Meadows tell Pat Cipollone, the White House counsel, Trump “didn’t want to do anything” to stop it.
AdvertisementFinally, ABC reports notable evidence about Trump’s 6 p.m. tweet after the violence ended: “These are the things and events that happen when a sacred landslide election victory is … viciously stripped away from great patriots…. Remember this day for forever!”
ABC reported that Trump posted the message despite Luna’s warning “that it made him sound ‘culpable’ for the violence, perhaps even as if he may have somehow been involved in ‘directing’ it.” Thus, he was on notice from a trusted ally that the message conveyed his criminal responsibility for the violence, and he published it anyway, demonstrating that it was no innocent mistake.
Advertisement AdvertisementOn Sunday, Trump’s team downplayed the significance of ABC’s blockbuster. A campaign spokesman said:
AdvertisementMedia fascination with second-hand hearsayshows just how weak the Witch-Hunt against President Trump is.”
This hearsay claim is 100 percent wrong. What witnesses told Trump and what he told them are not “hearsay” because the statements will not be offered in court to prove the truth of what they assert. Only statements offered for that purpose meet the legal definition of hearsay and are barred from being heard by jurors in criminal proceedings.
Take for example, Trump’s assertion to McCarthy that the Capitol invaders were “more concerned about the election” than he was. Smith would not offer that statement to prove its truth. Rather, Smith would offer the evidence to prove Trump’ criminal state of mind, a necessary element of every offense. Instead, the statement will be introduced to show that Trump wantedthe insurrection to continue and succeed in blocking the election certification.
The introduction of such testimony from Trump’s closest aides establishes his criminal intent and should seal his fate in the trial to come.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
Webb scientists haven't found a rocky world with air. But now they have a plan.Moon meets N. Korean delegation chief in PyeongChangMessi should show some respect: Brazil coach TiteKoreans spend 200,000 won monthly on childcare, despite state allowance: studyTop 10 Most Significant Nvidia GPUs of All TimeGov't will not seize savings from health insurance defaultersSignal expands encrypted group video calls to 40 people[PyeongChang 2018] PyeongChang Olympics leave legacy as Peace OlympicsWe Bought the Cheapest DDR5 RAM Modules We Could Find, Are They Any Good?KIS 5th graders showcase creative works at Eco Trade Show
下一篇:I used the Pixel 9 Pro XL in the shower — does the screen work when wet as claimed?
- ·Tesla's big software update includes something called 'Night Curfew'
- ·Senior teacher in Daegu dismissed over sexual misconduct
- ·US says denuclearization remains goal of any engagement with NK
- ·Ruling party scrambles to minimize fallout from sexual abuse scandal
- ·Aricell CEO arrested in first case under industrial accidents law
- ·International students get top honors at Korea, Sookmyung universities
- ·International students get top honors at Korea, Sookmyung universities
- ·N. Korea lobs coastal artillery shells into Yellow, East Seas: S. Korean military
- ·共同推动雅安职工思想政治引领数智化发展工作做深做实
- ·KIS 5th graders showcase creative works at Eco Trade Show
- ·Moon meets N. Korean delegation chief in PyeongChang
- ·Senior teacher in Daegu dismissed over sexual misconduct
- ·GPU Mining is Dead, Where are my Cheap GPUs?
- ·“中国首善”陈光标星夜赶赴芦山参与抢险救灾
- ·N. Korean leader sends congratulatory letter after Xi secures 3rd term
- ·S. Korea, US, Japan agree on more efforts against NK cryptocurrency theft
- ·Students get free entry at second Rawalpindi Test but what’s the catch?
- ·太平洋保险全速启动雅安地震灾区理赔服务 向灾区捐款500万元
- ·雅安芦山地震官方公布最新联系电话
- ·灾区道路多发危险 私人救援暂勿靠近
- ·[Graphic News] Average book price nears 20,000 won
- ·Seoul increases financial commitment to startups
- ·Two Cambodian men arrested on suspicion of attempted murder
- ·Elon Musk: Tesla could help to rebuild Puerto Rico's power grid
- ·Best Labor Day mattress deals in 2024
- ·求生 我们与死神赛跑
- ·Deceased K
- ·Elon Musk claims feature from Hummer EV is coming to quad
- ·Walking atop an explosive volcano, like White Island, is always dicey
- ·S. Korean, Russian foreign ministers vow to peacefully resolve NK nuke issue
- ·Webb telescope just snapped image of huge black hole gobbling material
- ·Walking atop an explosive volcano, like White Island, is always dicey
- ·“大排查、大教育、大整治”货车违法行为保道路交通安全
- ·Signal expands encrypted group video calls to 40 people
- ·Students get free entry at second Rawalpindi Test but what’s the catch?
- ·NK fires 2 short