Facebook finally appoints members to its Oversight Board, but will it really matter?
A Yemeni Nobel Peace Prize laureate who organized protests during the Arab Spring. The Vice President of the conservative Cato Institute who wrote a book titled "The Struggle to Limit Government." The former editor-in-chief of The Guardian when it was breaking news on the Edward Snowden’s leaked NSA documents.
What do the three people described here -- Tawakkol Karman, John Samples, and Alan Rusbridger -- have in common? They’re all members of Facebook’s new Oversight Board, often referred to as the platform’s “Supreme Court.”
On Wednesday, Facebookfinally unveiledthe first 20 people who will serve on the long-awaited Oversight Board. The independent board will rule over cases regarding content issues on the social network.
Since Facebook first made its plans for the independent Oversight Board public in 2018, the company had promised diversity among its members. Judging by that metric, CEO Mark Zuckerberg has lived up to the promise in a multitude of ways from gender and race to ideological diversity.
The 20 announcedmembers make up half of what will be a 40-person board. Half of those announced today are male, half are female. Collectively, the members of the board have lived in more than 27 countries and speak at least 29 different languages.
So far, the United States has the most representation on the board, with at least five members. The rest of the board spans the globe, with no other country currently having more than one representative on the board.
Daily content decisions will still be made by Facebook. The Oversight Board’s role, at least for now, is to make rulings on cases where specific content is removed from Facebook or Instagram. While it won’t be writing policy, these individual decisions from the board can certainly help shape it and provide guidance.
But, the biggest issue with the Oversight Board, however well-intentioned or diverse its membership is, is how limited in scope its powers over the social media giant are.
Yes, the Oversight Board has the ability to overrule even CEO Zuckerberg. Indeed, the board is its own independent corporate identity. The Oversight Board’s funding, however, comes from Facebook. In fact, the company itself chose the four co-chairs who in turn appoint the members of the board.
In addition, just because Zuckerberg can’t outright smack down a ruling, it doesn’t mean Facebook won’t have the final say.
Written out in the board’s own charter is a line that certainly gives Facebook carte blanche to opt out of practically any decision. Facebook says it will take action based on the Oversight Board’s decisions based on whether it’s “technically and operationally feasible.”
That’s fairly open and vague. It's also a pretty slick way of saying that none of what the Oversight Board rules is binding. If a decision from the board fundamentally changes the way an integral feature on Facebook works for the greater good, but it affects the company’s bottom line, does this wording give Facebook an out? Seems like it.
As NBC Newsalso points out, for a platform that has been criticizedfor its weak policieson misinformationand fake news, not a single person of the 20 announced on the board so far has a prominent background in disinformation.
With both the potential good and bad aspects of the Oversight Board laid out, it's far too early to deem it a failure or success. The board is expected to begin overseeing cases this summer. Then, we’ll see how this plays out.
下一篇:22 Unusual Things You Can Find in the Desert
- ·The Measurers
- ·今年夏季,雅安市级医院收治上百例毒蛇咬伤患者
- ·秋老虎“干精火旺” 要小心“情绪中暑”
- ·雅西高速15日起双向管制一个半月
- ·Best smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99
- ·提前规划 合理布局 推动发展
- ·雨城区中里镇群众 以共享理念发展乡村旅游
- ·百草枯农药毒性大 全面禁止销售使用
- ·How much for Oasis tickets? Fans joke about splurging on reunion shows
- ·我市举行“全民健身日”主题活动
- ·全城“蕉”点!广东香蕉闪耀广州塔
- ·【抗震救灾·雅电魂】人物志:“你们不要动,我去操作!”——记国家电网芦山响水滩电站站长余志清
- ·高燃!哨响表停赛不止,2024广东“村BA”开赛在即,一分钟带你重温高光瞬间。
- ·如何预防地震引发的次生地质灾害?
- ·秋老虎“干精火旺” 要小心“情绪中暑”
- ·秋老虎“干精火旺” 要小心“情绪中暑”
- ·The Analog Embrace: How Some Experiences Are Surviving the Digital Age
- ·装修公司:活动奖品作活饵 忽悠业主签“合同”
- ·百名志愿者探访湛江受助学生,恤孤助学会举办第十一届中秋大慰问活动
- ·省国土资源厅到我市检查闲置土地清理情况
- ·World’s first ‘meltdown
- ·汕尾:推动现代农业高质量发展,厚植丰收底蕴
- ·1至10月全市经济运行总体平稳
- ·并购重组尼德鲁公司 雅化国际化布局延伸至澳洲
- ·13 Astronomical Clocks Connecting Time And Space
- ·市委副书记、市长刘守培一行前往宝兴调研